Quantcast
Home arrow Fan Productions arrow Review: Of Gods and Men, Act 2
Saturday, 11 October 2008
 

TrekUnited Newsletter

Email
Confirm email
I prefer to receive
emails in HTML format

Click Here to Unsubscribe

View Newsletter Archive

 
 
 
Welcome Guest ( Register | Login )

  There are many great features available to you once you register at TrekUnited, including:
  • Richer content, access to many features that are disabled for guests like commenting on our news articles.
  • Create your own blog, or personal gallery.
  • Access to a great community, where you can interect with like minded individuals.
  • Access to our chat room, and guest chats.
  • Access to our network of sites, including Galactica.com.
  • Access to our submit news feature, members can try their hand at online journalism.
  • It's simple, it's easy and it's free
 



Review: Of Gods and Men, Act 2
Written by Derek Kessler on Tuesday, 11 March 2008
Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2To paraphrase Garrett Wang’s Commander Garan, “You’re going to enjoy this.” Building on the surprising, complex, and moderately confusing story of Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 1, the second act of the alternate-universe saga plunges head-first into rich characters and a tragic universe. If you thought Act 1 was good, then Act 2 will blow you away.
   
Act 2 opens with a brief refresher as to the ending of the first act: Vulcan is obliterated, and Koval (J.G. Hertzler) delivers a perfectly Klingon “You must dominate! Or be dominated.” Unlike Act 1, the secondary characters – Ragnar (Gary Graham), Xela (Chase Masterson), and Yara (Crystal Allen), in particular – get more screen time and add a new level of depth of the film. They aren’t just props or sidekicks, they’re cohorts and players in the game.

Makeup work is just as good as last time, though the Cardassian makeup did leave a bit to be desired. Unlike most other fan films, Of Gods and Men uses a lot of prosthetic makeup devices, especially on the great number of Klingons on the set. Wardrobe is wonderfully detailed, with subtle touches like a buckle here or a sash there to complete the look.

The fantastic sets of provided by Star Trek: Phase II (formerly New Voyages) are used to full effect and are artfully augmented by the addition of new control panels and screens. Camera work and editing are for the most part very well done, and the lighting adjustments made to the Enterprise set that much more set the dark tone of this alternate universe. Sound mixing is occasionally off, with off-screen speakers sometimes sounding as they were picked up by another actor’s microphone, or a phaser effect not matching the time that it is fired, but overall it’s very well put together.

The dialogue is much sharper and well-delivered in Act 2, but physical acting in the action scenes is generally very clumsy and takes away from the realism of those sequences. Walter Koenig as Kitrick/Chekov gives a wonderfully emotional performance, as do Nichelle Nichols (Uhura) and Alan Ruck (Harriman).

Like Star Trek of old, Of Gods and Men tackles modern issues, though in our day and age it takes on non-interference vs. security, terrorism vs. freedom fighters, war vs. peace, and so on. Unfortunately, the debate isn’t always as entwined in the story as it ought to be, but at the very least it presents compassionate arguments for both sides of the story. Star Trek at its best has always tackled these sort of issues, but in a manner that meshed it into the story, not just in face-to-face dialogue between the combatants.

As before, the computer graphics are beautifully done, and the Justin R. Durban soundtrack is powerful, artfully orchestrated, and used perfectly to enhance the changing moods of Of Gods and Men. Thankfully, the Dragonfly internet delivery system this time has already been through it’s trial-by-fire with the release of Act 1 and InAlienable, and thusly we get a much higher quality picture than last time. All things considered, it’s easy to forget that this is not a professional production. The acting of Ruck, Koenig, and the others with the directing of Tim Russ bump the bar up another notch again.

Line of the film goes to Harriman, after Garan informs him that, “It’s a trap.” He nods subtly and glances at him from the corner of his eye, “No... really?”

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2, runs for 33 minutes and while it answers plenty of the questions left open at the end of Act 1, it leave much more to be explained in Act 3, and certainly leaves me wanting more. It will be available on Saturday, March 15, at 1701 hours (that's 5:01 EDT).

4 1/2 stars

Read: Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 1 Review
Watch: Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2 (online March 15)
Discuss: TrekUnited Forum

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men, Act 2

Star Trek: Of Gods and Men
Starring:
Crystal Allen
James Cawley
Gary Graham
Walter Koenig
Cirroc Lofton
Chase Masterson
Lawrence Montaigne
Nichelle Nichols
Ethan Phillips
Alan Ruck
Tim Russ
Garrett Wang

Directed by:
Tim Russ

 Executive Producer:
RH McRoberts

Produced by:
Sky Conway

Written by:
Sky Conway
Tim Russ
Jack Trevino
Ethan H Calk

Music by:
Justin R Durban

Director of Photography:
Doug Knapp



Did you enjoy this article? Please bookmark it onto:
Reddit!Del.icio.us!Spurl!Wists!Simpy!Newsvine!Blinklist!Furl!Fark!Blogmarks!Yahoo!Smarking!Netvouz!Shadows!RawSugar!Ma.gnolia!FeedMeLinks!BlinkBits!Tailrank!linkaGoGo!Add this social bookmarking functionality to your website! title=
PDF Print E-mail
 
< Prev   Next >

"No being is so important that he can usurp the rights of another."

 

 
 

 

 
     
 

© 2008 TrekUnited - Uniting Star Trek Fans
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.
Template Design By: RoosterVision