[B'atL'eth's Blood]

TOS because when you get right down to it, it ain't about strength or size in REAL fight....It's about attitude, the TOS crew has it..They are willing to do what ever it takes, and thats the edge in a fight...

[Maco Captain]

ENT would win because of the MACO fighting force present on their ship.

[CharlieTucker]

Maco Captain, on Aug 3 2007, 12:48 PM, said:

ENT would win because of the MACO fighting force present on their ship.

I agree with you Captain. MACO's would totally win.

[B'atL'eth's Blood]

Oh so sorry! did you not take into account all the redshirts? Or the fact the TOS crew is very much like the 300 Spartans? Willing to fight and die for JTK & Co.? I thought not...

[ensign edwards]

I just meant the main cast, so no MACOs or 300 spartan red shirts.

[poko]

ensign edwards, on Aug 4 2007, 11:31 AM, said:

I just meant the main cast, so no MACOs or 300 spartan red shirts.

Well that takes out a lot of fun.

Well TNG would win because they have Worf and Data and in a strait fight it's hard to beat Data. Kirk might try to destroy him with bad logic but I think Data is above that.

DS9 would come in second because they have Odo, Worf, Kira, who has experience as a freedom fighter, and Sisko, who fights dirty. "You hit me! Picard never hit me!"

TOS would be third, but only because they'll have a slow start. They don't have an upper hand until Kirk loses his shirt. After that, he'll do something amazing like make a primitive gunpowder canon... 'cuz he's talented like that. Scotty would take someone out by getting them drunk and Spock would kick ass uber-Vulcan style. Hopefully, Uhura will keep her cloths on.

ENT would be next. They know how to live on the edge and they have a great Vulcan who can distract Kirk and Riker with her boobs. Also, if things get really desperate, Shran will show up and help save the day.

VOY would be last. Sure they have a Klingon and a two Vulcans but how often do those Vulcans ever do anything? Tuvok never tried to kill Janeway even once! This crew is just too concerned with the prime directive and talking about their morals to be that effective, with the exception of Seven. Seven will probably take out 5 or 6 people before she goes down. Janeway might get one or two after she finishes thinking about the moral implications.

This post has been edited by poko: 04 August 2007 - 05:41 PM

[ColonialMarine]

Voyager! Cause the crew is battle hardened. And cause Janeway kicks butt and takes names.

[Cougar]

poko, on Aug 4 2007, 06:27 PM, said:

Well that takes out a lot of fun.

Well TNG would win because they have Worf and Data and in a strait fight it's hard to beat Data. Kirk might try to destroy him with bad logic but I think Data is above that.

DS9 would come in second because they have Odo, Worf, Kira, who has experience as a freedom fighter, and Sisko, who fights dirty. "You hit me! Picard never hit me!"

TOS would be third, but only because they'll have a slow start. They don't have an upper hand until Kirk loses his shirt. After that, he'll do something amazing like make a primitive gunpowder canon... 'cuz he's talented like that. Scotty would take someone out by getting them drunk and Spock would kick ass uber-Vulcan style. Hopefully, Uhura will keep her cloths on.

ENT would be next. They know how to live on the edge and they have a great Vulcan who can distract Kirk and Riker with her boobs. Also, if things get really desperate, Shran will show up and help save the day.

VOY would be last. Sure they have a Klingon and a two Vulcans but how often do those Vulcans ever do anything? Tuvok never tried to kill Janeway even once! This crew is just too concerned with the prime directive and talking about their morals to be that effective, with the exception of Seven. Seven will probably take out 5 or 6 people before she goes down. Janeway might get one or two after she finishes thinking about the moral implications.

I love it

[ColonialMarine]

Quote

ENT would be next. They know how to live on the edge and they have a great Vulcan who can distract Kirk and Riker with her boobs.

I like Vulcan boobies.

[Aussie Trekkie]

ENT because Malcolm, Trip and T'Pol all know how to use weapons

Malcolm knows all about the conventional weapons (phase pistols, explosives etc)
Trip can disarm any lady with his southern charm
T'Pol has good logic and beauty which are useful in any order

[NXO1]

DS9 crew they have Worf, Kira, Sisko, and Jadzia Dax not Ezri. don't get me wrong i like Ezri but Jadzia is a warrior.

[trekkin']

TOS....Didn't you see Urura kick butt with Kirk and ...was it Chekov???I think so. If it were a girl fight...I've got my money on her.

Tough call though. But I always fall back to the original!!

[CharlieTucker]

Still the Enterprise crew has the MACO force on their ship and their the best in Starfleet

[ensign edwards]

Quote

ENT because Malcolm, Trip and T'Pol all know how to use weapons

Don't forget black belt Hoshi.

[Commander Lazar]

I think TNG because of the super-strong Data and the super-strong Worf.

This post has been edited by Commander Lazar: 20 June 2011 - 03:53 PM

[Allee]

I can't believe no one mentioned Wesley Crusher and his dazzling sweater collection that could surely distract any opponent, crippling them with the mental torture of repeatedly thinking, "Uhhhhhhhhhhh!?!?!?!? "

So Wesley and his 80s Bill Cosby sweater collection; followed rather closely by Jake Sisko and his. . . whatever the hell he's wearing; followed by Neelix and his. . . again, whatever the hell he's wearing; and to round out the team. . . Voyager's Icheb who apparently checked the data files to see what Wesley might have worn had he been living, a few years later, in the Delta Quadrant. The 4 of them, working together, could totally incapacitate all the crews with their bad taste.

[Beast Boy]

I think,what real fight battle have in series "DS9",because in one episode captain Sisco fight phaser rifle Jem'Hadar.In "TOS" battle see do not real.In "Voy" have fight,but this small.Me like only "DS9" and battle in this series.

This post has been edited by Martok: 22 August 2011 - 06:34 AM

[ensign edwards]

Allee, on 21 August 2011 - 11:33 AM, said:

I can't believe no one mentioned Wesley Crusher and his dazzling sweater collection that could surely distract any opponent, crippling them with the mental torture of repeatedly thinking, "Uhhhhhhhhhhh!?!?!?!? "

So Wesley and his 80s Bill Cosby sweater collection; followed rather closely by Jake Sisko and his. . . whatever the hell he's wearing; followed by Neelix and his. . . again, whatever the hell he's wearing; and to round out the team. . . Voyager's Icheb who apparently checked the data files to see what Wesley might have worn had he been living, a few years later, in the Delta Quadrant. The 4 of them, working together, could totally incapacitate all the crews with their bad taste.

[Legolas]

Well, i, for one, choose TOS crew over TNG crew for the victory. Kirk always has some tribbles up his sleaves if he meets Klingons so Worf would be going nuts all over the ship after Kirk would beam those tribbles into every single area of the enterprise. Data, who has still trouble with his newly fused-in emotions chip, would go crazy about those cute furballs and would duke it out with Worf over their safety- That just leaves the regular humans of the original cast in TNG, whom TOS crew would beat the phlox out of (wrote the phlox myself)

[jonathan]

I say ENT, with two martial artists and 2 secret agents and Xindi experience!!!